X-MEN: APOCALYPSE [Review]

XMenApocalypsePoster
X-MEN APOCALYPSE/ Directed by BRYAN SINGER/ Screenplay by SIMON KINBERG, BRYAN SINGER, MICHAEL DOUGHERTY & DAN HARRIS/ Starring JAMES MCAVOY, MICHAEL FASSBENDER, JENNIFER LAWRENCE, NICHOLAS HOULT, OSCAR ISAAC, ROSE BYRNE, EVAN PETERS, JOSH HELMAN, SOPHIE TURNER, TYE SHERIDAN, LUCAS TILL, KODI SMIT-MCPHEE, BEN HARDY, ALEXANDRA SHIPP, LANA CONDOR & OLIVIA MUNN/ Produced by 20TH CENTURY FOX FILM CORP, TSG ENTERTAINMENT, BAD HAT HARRY PRODUCTIONS & MARVEL ENTERTAINMENT/ Distributed by 20TH CENTURY FOX FILM CORP.

[WARNING – This review of X-Men: Apocalypse contains SPOILERS.]

The year is 1973. Following his assault on President Richard Nixon, ferromancer Erik Lehnsherr became Public Enemy Number One. Shapeshifter Raven Darkholme inadvertently became the face of a movement and a hero to thousands of young people after stopping the assassination attempt. And Charles Xavier, the world’s most powerful telepath, returned home to build a school for gifted youths – mutants with powers, like himself and his former allies, Raven and Erik.

Fast forward ten years. Erik is happily living under an assumed name in his native Poland, with a wife and daughter. Raven is wandering the world, denying that she’s any kind of hero while still helping young mutants to survive. Charles is still running his school, with the aid of his friend Hank McCoy. And the world is enjoying an uneasy peace, though the existence of mutants has been publicly known for a decade and the events of ten years ago are now taught in high-school history classes.

What few suspect and even fewer know is that mutants are not a recent phenomena. Thousands of years ago in Egypt, one existed whose power threatened to enslave humanity for all time. The bold action of a few brave soldiers managed to entrap the god-emperor En Sabah Nur under his pyramid. Or so it was hoped…

Now, En Sabah Nur has been awoken! And he is not pleased with the world that has been built in his absence – a decadent place where the weak exploit the strong with their own rules and laws. It is a world ripe for salvation.

Unfortunately, En Saban Nur’s ideas for salvation are decidedly Old Testament and involve a cleansing fire which will burn the world to ashes, leaving him and his chosen followers to rebuild a better world after the apocalypse. And the only thing that may stop En Sabah Nur and his newly appointed horsemen is an uneasy alliance of old friends and green recruits.

XMenApocalypsePic2In considering X-Men: Apocalypse, I am reminded of a quote from Oscar Wilde, from when he was visiting the United States and was asked what he thought of it – “There is much to admire here, but on reflection I believe everything admirable was imported from elsewhere.”

Did you enjoy the Quicksilver scene from Days of Future Past? Or the scene where Magneto kills a bunch of people with one small metal object like in X-2? What about the conversation between Xavier and Magneto regarding someone attacking the school from the end of the original X-Men? Good news! You’ll get to see these scenes and more repeated here!

This repetition extends to the characters themselves, as the main cast repeat their character beats from the previous movies. Michael Fassbender rages over the death of his second family and continues to insist that he is beyond saving, until he isn’t. Jennifer Lawrence continues to insist that she isn’t a hero, until the script requires her to do something heroic. And James McAvoy continues to insist that everyone has good in them until they prove him right.

The rest of the ensemble does the best they can with the weak script. Yet most of them have little to do but stand in the background and pose dramatically. This is particularly true of The Four Horsemen, with the exception of Magneto, whose sudden willingness to subvert his will in the name of Apocalypse is never convincingly explained.

XMenApocalypsePic1

The film’s biggest problem is Apocalypse himself. His power levels and abilities have always been vaguely defined and his design was over-the-top in the fashion typical of Dark Age Marvel baddies. One wonders why he needs minions in the first place, given how powerful he is. And while the character’s final appearance doesn’t look quite as bad as the early pictures that drew comparison to Ivan Ooze from Power Rangers The Movie, the design doesn’t work. And any sense of subtlety or menace in Oscar Isaac’s performance is completely lost behind five pounds of make-up and the continual reverb in his auto-tuned voice.

By any fair metric, X-Men: Apocalypse is a terrible movie. The direction is sub-par, with dramatic scenes suddenly interrupted by comedic beats. The story is confusing, even ignoring the many plot holes and contradictions regarding the previous X-Men films. And most of the characters could be replaced by cardboard cut-outs with nothing being lost.

In this, the film effectively (if unintentionally) captures the sensation of reading the average X-Men comic perfectly. The visuals are more important than the story and more effort has been put into making sure Olivia Munn looks like Psylocke than in giving her anything to do. Die-hard X-Fans will be doubtlessly be pleased by this movie but everyone else would do well to skip this one or wait for it to hit their Netflix queue.

Rating 2

About Matt Morrison

Matt "Starman" Morrison is The Grand Exalted High Macha of Raspur - a non-existent but real-sounding country. He has been writing about comics since before the word "blogging" was coined. He enjoys acting, role-playing, movie-riffing and sarcasm. You can follow his adventures on Twitter, @GeekyGeekyWays.

4 comments on “X-MEN: APOCALYPSE [Review]

  1. But… better than X3, right? That’s really all I ask for with X-Men movies these days. First Class was a blessing, and Days of Future Past was pretty good. So an “eh, all right” Apocalypse would be fine with me.

    I’m sure I’ll have thoughts (which I’ll share) once I see it!

  2. Went and saw Apocalypse over the weekend, and for the most part, I agree with your take. The film does sort of play as the X-Men film’s greatest hits, more like a string of moments than a cohesive film. And Apocalypse himself is a big miss, which is unfortunate given the enormous presence he has in X-Men lore. I’d say the film’s first two acts are strong, but it just kind of fizzles with the third.

    Still, for all that, I really enjoyed it. That speaks more to me as a fan of the X-Men, and these versions of them in particular, but it doesn’t excuse the movie’s problems. I think I’d have given it a 3/5, but no higher than that. For me, it sits directly between BvS and Civil War. I’ll definitely be seeing this one again because as a fan (particularly of that 90s cartoon) I dig it, flaws and all.

    I’ll also say I found a lot to love about each characters’ arcs, and for the main three (Xavier, Magneto, Mystique) I felt their stories were brought closure in a manner I enjoyed. Like, were this the last time I saw those three, it’d be fitting. Particular the moments between Charles and Erik, those are on the same level as anything McAvoy and Fassbender have done in previous films.

    That said, I think the new generation of X-Men come of even better, so in that regard I’m very excited for where the series goes next. I really wish we had actually seen them in the mall, that’d have been a cool moment. That scene was cut since it was in early photos and maybe even a trailer. So I’m also convinced there was a lot of this movie cut that may have improved its coherency.

    But most of all, I found this movie fun! I mean, yes, there are totally things that happen because, ‘Hey, it’s an X-Men movie!’, but it’s enjoyable to watch. Again, that may just be me fangirling, but seeing characters like Magneto, Cyclops, Jean Grey, and Nightcrawler really get to go wild with their powers, that’s the stuff I like to see. Even Psylocke, since that’s literally all she had was a few cool action beats.

    P.S. My heart goes out to anyone who’s a huge Angel fan, because for the second threequel in a row, he’s the most worthless character. Here’s a tad better here than he is in X3, but he’s still the worst.

    1. Yeah. Maybe there was cut material that would make this better… but there were two things I singled out in talks elsewhere I would like to have seen.

      1. Nightcrawler going nuts over the lightsaber fights in Return of the Jedi. We get the quick nod to Kurt’s religious nature but we have yet to see the swashbuckling, Errol Flynn loving side of him on film.

      2. Beast geeking out over Weapon X’s jet. I would have killed for him to say “Oh my stars and garters… this ship is completely non-metallic!” so they could get the line drop AND explain just why that plane was able to function when Magneto is generating a world-wide magnetic field and ripping metal out of the earth. I mean, it would totally make sense for Weapon X to develop something like that given how paranoid Stryker was and given that Erik was Public Enemy #1.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *